Showing posts with label SS ARTIST. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SS ARTIST. Show all posts

Sunday, November 4, 2012

Naval casualties on St James' Memorial


The table below details the men on the St James Memorial who died serving with the Merchant Navy, the Royal Navy or the Naval Reserve. The information given is the service they were in, their service number (if applicable) the ship or base they were on when they died and ther date of death.

Name
Surname
 
Service number
Ship/base
Date of death
Herbert Loyd
Hill
Merchant Navy
 
SS ARABIC
19/08/1915
Samuel J
Tonkies
Merchant Navy
 
SS ARTIST
27/01/1917
Owen
Owen
Merchant Navy
 
SS STUART PRINCE
22/03/1917
William
Elliott
Merchant Navy
 
SS HUNTSTRICK
08/06/1917
Ernest C
Benn
Merchant Navy
 
SS OLYMPIC
20/03/1918
James
Tonkies
Merchant Navy
 
SS BURUTU
03/10/1918
Richard W
Longmaid
Merchant Navy Reserve
763081
HMS ALCANTARA
29/02/1916
William
Beattie
Royal Navy
SS/107737
HOWE BN
04/06/1915
Thomas H
Bramwell
Royal Navy
233784
HMS INVINCIBLE
31/05/1916
James
Wilding
Royal Navy
SS/110409
HMS INDEFATIGABLE
31/05/1916
Matthew
Chisam
Royal Naval Reserve
2062D
HMS PRESIDENT III
24/09/1917


Monday, June 25, 2012

Samuel J Tonkies

This record was all a bit of a puzzle. Although I could find Samuel Joseph Tonkies in the census records, there was no listing for Samuel J Tonkies in the ancestry.co.uk military database, nor in the CWGC database.  There was however a G J Tonkies on the CWGC database whose 'other information' showed that he was the son of Mary Jane Tonkies of Liverpool. This matched the census records I had found for Samuel. As he didn't have a brother with the initials G.J. I assumed that the record was in fact for him and had somehow been mis-transcribed as G.
I tried to confirm this with the merchant seaman records on the national archives online but the only record I could find was for John Edward Tonkies (a brother of S.J.)

I then got in touch with an ancestry member whose wife is a descendant of the Tonkies family and they confirmed that the G.J. Tonkies record was Samuel. They didn't know why his name was wrong or why it hadn't been corrected.
***********
Samuel Joseph Tonkies was born on 25th April 1895. He was bptised on 5th June 1895 in St Gabriel, Toxteth. The baptism record (below) shows that his parents were John Edward and Mary Jane Tonkies. They lived at 21 Guest Street, Toxteth and John Edward's occupation was Engine Driver.

source:ancestry.co.uk
The 1901 census return shows the Tonkies family lived at 24 Guest Street,  John Edward (head of the household) was an engine driver (stationary) Samuel J was 5 years old and the 5th of 7 children.
source:ancestry.co.uk

In the 1911 census return the family were living at 10 Rhyl Street, Toxteth. The number of children seems to have been misunderstood as it says 7 born, 2 died and 5 living. However from census returns, birth and baptism records I can identify a total of 10 children, 2 of whom died.
Other details from the census return show that Samuel Joseph Tonkies was 16 and working as a plumber's labourer.
Just to confuse matters further, Ancestry.co.uk has for some reason got this census return listed twice with small differences in transcription (eg John Edward's place of birth is Salford in one, Liverpool in the other)
source:ancestry.co.uk

The CWGC record for Samuel is under the name G.J. Tonkies but I am sure it is the right man as it gives his mother's name as Mary Jane. There is not another Mary Jane Tonkies in the census returns or birth records, there is also no G.J. Tonkies.

click here to see the CWGC entry for G.J. Tonkies

Samuel was in the Mercantile Marine (Merchant Navy) but his death was eligible for CWGC status because he was killed as a direct result of enemy action.

The death at sea index (below) also has the name G.J. Tonkies. These sources show that Samuel was a fireman and trimmer on the SS Artist which was sunk by enemy on 27th Jan 1917. Samuel was 'supposed drowned.'


source: deaths at sea index findmypast.co.uk 


CLICK HERE TO GO TO A POST ON THIS BLOG CONTAINING THE TEXT OF  WARTIME PAMPHLET ABOUT THE SINKING OF THE SS ARTIST (opens in new window)


sinking of the SS ARTIST - leaflet

The following text is from what I assume is a wartime leaflet. The source for the original pdf file was sourced from the University of Colorado library WW1 digital collection.

Murder Again !

Now that the shadow of disaster hangs over her, Germany

resorts to deeds of shame such as the world has never known.

The Secretary of the British Admiralty makes the following

announcement :

The British ss. " Artist," when 48 miles from land in a

heavy easterly gale, was torpedoed by a German submarine

on Saturday morning, January 27th. In response to her

appeal, sent by wireless, " S.O.S., sinking quickly," auxiliary

patrol craft proceeded to the spot and searched the vicinity,

but found no trace of the vessel or her survivors.

Three days later the ss. " Luchana " picked up a boat

containing 16 of the survivors. The boat had originally contained

23, but seven had died of wounds and exposure, and

were buried at sea. The surviving 16 were landed, and of

these five were suffering from severe frostbite and one from

a broken arm.

The crew had been forced to abandon their ship in open

boats in a midwinter gale, and utterly without means of

reaching land or succour.

Those of them who perished during those three days of

bitter exposure were murdered, and to pretend that anything

was done to ensure their safety would be sheer hypocrisy.

The pledge given by Germany to the United States not

to sink merchant ships without ensuring the safety of the

passengers and crews has been broken before, but never in

circumstances of more cold-blooded brutality.

Printed in Great Britain by Sir Joseph Cattston & Snns, Ltd., 9, Eastcheap, London, E.C.

"BUT NINE OF HER CREW ALIVE"

The following account of the sinking of the SS Artist is an extract from the book 

The merchant seaman in war
by L. Cope Cornford, with a foreword by Admiral Sir John R. Jellicoe.

Published 1918 by George H. Doran Company in New York.
Written in English.

 
 
 
"BUT NINE OF HER CREW ALIVE" 
 
NINE O'CLOCK on the morning of January 27th, 
1917, in very dirty weather, in the North Atlantic. 
One of his Majesty's patrol boats fighting out a 
full easterly gale with a breaking sea, smothered 
in water, violently flung to and fro. To the 
lieutenant-commander, R.N.R., comes a mes- 
senger with a signal pad, on which is neatly 
written an intercepted wireless S.O.S. call : 
" S.S. Artist sinking rapidly, mined or torpedoed 
in ' then followed her position. The lieu- 
tenant-commander replied by wireless that he 
was proceeding to her assistance. No answer 
came, then or afterwards. The lieutenant - 
commander increased his speed up to the limit 
the boat could stand in that sea, and steered for 
the spot indicated. He shoved along for two 
hours ; then, as the vessel was being strained 
and the engines were racing, he reduced speed ; 
an hour later he was obliged again to reduce 
speed. At half-past one he arrived at the 
position indicated. There was nothing but the 
boiling waste of waters. 
 
The lieutenant-commander cruised twelve 
miles in one direction and twelve miles in another ; 
the wind increasing, the sea rising higher, the 
cold very bitter. 
 
At three o'clock in the afternoon the lieu- 
tenant-commander was obliged to heave-to. He 
did not think that in such weather the boats of 
the sinking ship could have been launched, or if 
they were launched, that they could live. That 
night it blew harder than ever, and the thermo- 
meter fell to 37 degrees. At nine o'clock the 
next morning the lieutenant-commander went 
to succour another ship in distress, and so passes 
out of this story. 
 
He was right and wrong in his surmise. A 
little after the lieutenant-commander had 
received the S.O.S. call from the Artist, the 
boats had been launched from her, and one lived. 
While the lieutenant-commander, the same 
afternoon, was beating to and fro in the raging 
sea and icy spindrift, there was a boat with its 
miserable crew somewhere near. 
 
It was between eight and nine on that Saturday 
morning, January 27th, 1917, when the Artist's 
wireless operator sent out his call. The Artist, 
sailing from an American port, had run right 
into the gale ; and she had been hove-to for 
three nights and two days. Between eight and 
nine in the morning, without a sign of a submarine, 
the dull boom of an explosion roared through the 
tumult of the gale, and a torpedo, striking the 
starboard side forward, tore a huge hole close 
upon the water-line. 
 
There was not a moment to lose. The violent 
pitching of the ship, lying head to sea, ominously 
slackened as she began to settle by the head. The 
sea poured over her bows and swept the decks 
from stem to stern. Waist-deep in water, the 
crew struggled desperately to lower the three 
lifeboats. In one boat were the master with the 
second and third officers and part of the crew ; 
in another were the chief officer and part of 
the crew ; and in the third were a cadet and 
part of the crew. What followed is taken from 
the cadet's narrative. 
 
He was in his boat, which was swung out on 
the falls, and he saw the chief officer's boat, also 
swung out, dashed against the ship's side as 
she rolled, and broken. The next moment the 
cadet's boat was borne upwards by a rising wave, 
so that the after fall was pushed upwards and 
thus unhooked. As the boat was left hanging 
by the bows her stern dropped suddenly. Two 
men were flung overboard and sank at once. 
The next wave bodily lifting the boat on an 
even keel, enabled the cadet to unhook the 
foremost fall, and the men, pulling hard, got 
clear of the ship. 
 
As he pulled clear, the cadet saw the chief 
officer's boat filled with water to the gunwale, 
broadside on to the tremendous sea, and help- 
less. She was never seen again. 
 
In the meanwhile the master's boat had also 
pulled clear of the sinking ship. Both boats laid 
out sea anchors and drifted in sight of each other 
all that terrible day. 
 
There were forty-five persons in all on board 
the Artist when she was torpedoed. Some had  
gone down in the chief officer's boat, some were 
in the captain's boat, and in the cadet's boat were 
sixteen persons. 
 
That night, the night of January 27th, as 
the lieutenant-commander stated, the gale 
increased in violence and the thermometer 
dropped to 37 degrees. Somehow, the frozen, 
wet, exhausted men must keep baling out the 
boat, and her head to the sea. Concerning the 
horrors of that night the cadet says nothing. 
It is possible that the partial paralysis of the 
faculties, induced by long exposure, dulls the 
memory. There is no consciousness of time, but 
a quite hopeless conviction of eternity. The 
state of men enduring prolonged and intense 
hardship seems to them to have had no beginning 
and to have no end. After a period of acute 
suffering, varying according to the individual, 
the edge of pain is blunted and numbness sets 
in. In many cases the retardation of the 
circulation, withdrawing the full supply of 
blood to the head, causes delirium, in which 
men shout and babble, drink salt water, and 
leap overboard. By degrees the heart's action 
is weakened, and finally stops. Then the 
man dies. Seven men in the cadet's boat did 
in fact die. 
 
After the night of the 27th the captain's boat 
was no more seen. The cadet and his crew alone 
were left of the people of the Artist. 
 
They drifted in the gale all that Sunday, the 
28th, all Monday, all Monday night. Men died, 
one after another, and the pitiless sea received 
their bodies. When each one passed the cadet  
does not state. Probably he could not remember. 
For the survivors were dying, too. They were 
dying upwards from their feet, in which frost- 
bite had set in. One man, a fireman, endured 
the agony of a broken arm. . . . 
 
On the night of January 29th-30th, when 
the castaways had been adrift for three days 
and three nights, they saw the distant lights of 
land towards the north. The wind and sea 
began to go down, and at daylight the crew 
hoisted sail and steered north. At a little 
after nine on that Tuesday morning, exactly 
seventy-two hours since they had cleared the 
sinking ship, they sighted the smoke of an 
outward-bound steamer. Twenty minutes later 
nine men were taken on board, and one dead 
man was left in the boat. 
 
The rescued men were transferred to a 
patrol boat, which landed them in an Irish 
port the same evening. Here, says the cadet, 
" the Shipwrecked Mariners' authorities took 
care of us and did all they possibly could 
for us." 
 
Five of the nine survivors were placed in 
hospital. The remaining four, of whom the 
sturdy cadet was one, speedily recovered. 
 
The boat with the dead man in her was picked 
up by a patrol vessel. 
 
A brief official account of the affair was 
published at the time by the Secretary of the 
Admiralty, who remarked that ' The pledge 
given by Germany to the United States not to 
sink merchant ships without ensuring the safety 
of the passengers and crews has been broken 
 before, but never in circumstances of more 
cold-blooded brutality." 
 
But when it comes to brutality the Germans 
can do better than that, as will be seen. What's 
the use of talking ?